To be fair - anyone who saw Lloyd play saw the potential. In fact, he made one of the most amazing catches I've ever seen in a game against Seattle. (Just watch the first 38 seconds of the clip below to see the catch.)
But, at the end of the day his rap "career", locker room demeanor, and harrowing ability to duck away from footballs thrown at him sealed his doom.
I thought it might be interesting to see what the draft picks that the 49ers received for Lloyd turned out to be. Now, 3 to 4 years later, were those picks worth more than a petulant and inconsistent wide receiver?
The 49ers traded Lloyd to Redskins and in return drafted Brandon Williams (3rd round in 2006) and Jay Moore (4th round in 2007). Brandon Williams was drafted as a receiver/returner and fizzled out quickly in San Francisco. He was picked up by St. Louis in 2007 and was part of their final round of cuts. He played in the pre-season for the Steelers in 2009 and didn't make it past the final round of cuts.
A 3rd pick not even making the roster after year one - Verdict? BIG BUST.
Jay Moore was drafted as one of those tweeners that thrive in a 3-4 defense. In 2007, Mike Nolan was still trying to assemble the components of his 3-4/4-3 defense and Moore was supposed to have a rotational role in that scheme. He was placed on injured reserve after the final pre-season game in 2007 and in 2008 and it was viewed as kind of a good thing. Moore was going to need to learn how to play linebacker and a season on IR would help that come along.
The injury bug struck again in 2008 and Moore tore one of his triceps. He was signed to the Rams practice squad in 2009 and then kind-of signed with the Cowboys before backing out of the deal at the last second. He now plays for the Omaha Nighthawks of the United Football League.
No regular season games played and 2 trips to IR - Verdict? BUST.
Interestingly enough, the extra picks from the Lloyd trade allowed us to trade up in 2006 (due to an extra third round pick) and get Manny Lawson. And in 2007 the extra 4th was part of the package that helped us land Joe Staley.
In the end, it looks like the players we got for Lloyd were absolute busts. But the extra picks gave us some flexibility in the draft, allowing us to draft Lawson and Staley.
Waiting on a player to finally get his head on straight after 7 years in the NFL or getting draft picks that indirectly resulted in two-starters? It wasn't the fleecing we thought, but even in retrospect it was a move the 49ers would (and should) make again.
Especially after hearing this...
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers WR Brandon Aiyuk appears to take shot at Kyle Shanahan after car accident
San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan accepted responsibility Tuesday for the car accident that left him with a broken nose, three broken ribs, a broken hand, a severe concussion, and facial injuries requiring 40 stitches. Shanahan explained that the initial police... -
49ers training camp set to deliver harsh reality to attention-seeking Brandon Aiyuk
Brandon Aiyuk has spent much of the offseason making sure people know exactly how he feels. The current (and soon-to-be former) San Francisco 49ers wide receiver has used social media videos and posts to air his frustrations, take shots at the organization, make his feelings... -
John Lynch sends a clear message on Brandon Aiyuk situation as 49ers training camp begins
The biggest San Francisco 49ers storyline at the start of training camp is the health of head coach Kyle Shanahan, who is recovering from injuries sustained in a recent car accident. The good news is that none of Shanahan's injuries are considered life-threatening, and the... -
49ers named among top Vita Vea trade fits—but there's one reason for hesitation
Pro Bowl defensive tackle Vita Vea appears to have grown tired of waiting on the Tampa Bay Buccaneers to finalize a contract extension and has reportedly requested a trade. As is often the case when a star player becomes available, speculation has quickly made the San Francisco...