During his 14-year career, Staley has been part of some of the best and some of the worst teams in 49ers history. He has played for 2 Super Bowl teams, he also has suffered a 2-14 season. In the beginning of the Shanahan-Lynch era, Staley was pondering retirement. Head coach Kyle Shanahan was able to persuade Staley to look for the light at the end of the tunnel, coaxing him to stay and help the 49ers acquire their 6th Lombardi trophy.
Staley stayed, and on February 2nd 2020, the 49ers held a 10-point lead in the 4th quarter of Super Bowl 54. What seemed to be a crowning moment for a deserving veteran crumbled into another war story about what could have been. There has been speculation surrounding Staley retiring in 2020, but he has stated he plans to play out the new deal he signed in 2019 that made him a 49er through 2021. "Get one for Joe" should be plastered on the locker room walls until that contract expires.
2019 Performance
Injuries plagued Staley in 2019, causing him to miss 9 games. During the 7 games Staley did play he let up 2 sacks and was responsible for two penalties. Pro Football Focus graded Staley at a 72.7, the highest of any 49ers lineman in 2019. Despite his grade leading the 2019 49ers, it was Staley's worst grade since his 2010 season. Players who PFF graded at a similar level included Tennessee LT Taylor Lewan (73.4), Seattle LT Duane Brown (74.1) and Minnesota LT Riley Reiff (71.2).
2020 Cost
Staley carries a $11 million cap hit in 2020. If the 49ers part ways with Staley prior to 6/1/20, they would save $10 million in cap space.
Future Outlook
You don't remove the heart of your team coming off a Super Bowl loss. Not only is Joe Staley the best lineman the 49ers have, he is essential to the chemistry that made the 2019 49ers such a special team. If Staley wants to continue to play, the 49ers would be best served to keep that LT spot open for him. The next two years should consist of Joe playing out his contract and mentoring the younger lineman (particularly Justin Skule & Daniel Brunskill) in hopes one can replace him when his contact ends. If Staley's performance takes a steep dive, the 49ers will have to have a difficult conversation with the 49ers legend, whether it be retiring or restructuring for a more team friendly deal.
Next: No. 8 - Fred Warner
Written By:
49ers outsider, residing in the Hudson Valley, representing 30+ years of the 49ers experience
All articles by Gilbert Brink
@Brinkasaurus
YouTube Channel
Gilbert Brink
49ers outsider, residing in the Hudson Valley, representing 30+ years of the 49ers experience
All articles by Gilbert Brink
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers named among top Vita Vea trade fits—but there's one reason for hesitation
Pro Bowl defensive tackle Vita Vea appears to have grown tired of waiting on the Tampa Bay Buccaneers to finalize a contract extension and has reportedly requested a trade. As is often the case when a star player becomes available, speculation has quickly made the San Francisco... -
Can the 49ers' aging core hold on? Insider reveals top concern for 2026
The San Francisco 49ers enter the 2026 season with legitimate Super Bowl aspirations, as they have for several years. The roster is talented enough to make another deep playoff run, but can the team keep pace in what could be the NFL's toughest division? The NFC West features... -
Where 49ers TE George Kittle landed in the NFL Top 100 Players of 2026
The NFL continues its countdown of the NFL Top 100 Players of 2026, with San Francisco 49ers tight end George Kittle checking in at No. 46. The ranking represents a notable drop from last year's No. 31 spot and his No. 14 ranking in 2024. Despite the decline, Kittle is still... -
49ers' Fred Warner tumbles in NFL Top 100 after injury-shortened season
San Francisco 49ers linebacker Fred Warner is widely regarded as one of the NFL's premier defensive players. However, the four-time All-Pro's 2025 season was cut short by a significant right ankle injury, a setback that appears to have impacted his standing among his...