One respected evaluator who disagrees with that assessment is NFL analyst Greg Cosell. In fact, Cosell believes Black has a legitimate opportunity to carve out a significant role in the 49ers' offense as the primary backup to All-Pro running back Christian McCaffrey.
"I really liked his tape a lot," Cosell said on the Ross Tucker Podcast. "I think that he fits the way the 49ers play offense. He's tough. He's physical. He's got some juice to him. He gets hard yards. It would not surprise me if he earns the job as the backup to McCaffrey, because I thought his tape was really, really good."
Black broke out in 2025, rushing for 1,040 yards and 10 touchdowns while averaging 5.6 yards per carry. He produced those numbers despite sharing carries with Roman Hemby, helping lead Indiana to a national championship.
The rookie has also made a strong early impression on his new teammates.
"He's been great," McCaffrey said. "He's been everything you would want in a rookie—super attentive in meetings, does everything right, has a bunch of talent, and complements our room really well."
McCaffrey also highlighted Black's ability to absorb information quickly, a critical trait for any running back looking to earn playing time in head coach Kyle Shanahan's offense.
Seven-time Pro Bowl tight end George Kittle offered a simple but revealing assessment when asked about his early impressions of the rookie.
"Very fast," Kittle said. "Very fast and very mature."
While Black still has plenty to prove before the regular season begins, the early reviews have been overwhelmingly positive. Between Cosell's endorsement and the praise coming from veteran teammates, the rookie appears well-positioned to earn a meaningful role with his new team.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Robert Saleh names 49ers' biggest rookie surprise from last season
The San Francisco 49ers invested heavily in their defense during the 2025 NFL Draft, using six of their 11 selections on defensive players, including each of their first five picks. One rookie, however, stood out more than the rest to former 49ers defensive coordinator Robert... -
49ers rookie prediction highlights concerns about key offensive weapon
San Francisco 49ers star running back Christian McCaffrey is coming off an NFL Comeback Player of the Year campaign. In 2025, he totaled an impressive 2,126 scrimmage yards and 17 touchdowns, reestablishing himself as one of the NFL's most dynamic offensive weapons. McCaffrey... -
49ers roster battles: The undrafted rookie sleepers to watch
Every year, one or two undrafted rookies force the San Francisco 49ers to rethink their roster. From Matt Breida and Emmanuel Moseley to Jordan Mason, Jeff Wilson, Jr., and Azeez Al-Shaair, the 49ers have seen rookies earn opportunities after entering the league without hearing... -
Brandon Aiyuk throws shade at Kyle Shanahan, 49ers
Disgruntled wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk continues to take shots at the San Francisco 49ers on social media. This time, Aiyuk sarcastically suggested the 49ers want him back—a scenario that, at this point, seems highly unlikely. In the process, he also appeared to take a...