"Winters has not become a star but made tremendous strides during a 101-tackle 2025 campaign," Gagnon wrote. "He's not a lock to have a long starting career, but he's certainly a factor while working through a four-year, $4.0 million rookie deal."
San Francisco selected Winters out of TCU in the sixth round (No. 216 overall) of the 2023 NFL Draft. He is now entering the final year of that rookie contract after starting 17 games during the 2025 season.
His role could shift in 2026, however, with Dre Greenlaw returning to the 49ers following a one-season stint with the Denver Broncos. Even so, Winters proved his value last season by stepping into a full-time role.
While his 101 tackles stand out, his evaluations from Pro Football Focus suggest there is still room for growth. Winters posted a 60.1 defensive grade, along with marks of 64.3 in run defense, 53.2 in tackling, 56.4 as a pass rusher, and 59.6 in coverage.
Still, the 49ers getting 17 starts and triple-digit tackles from a player earning just over $1 million last season underscores why Winters belongs on Gagnon's underpaid list. He'll see a nice pay bump in 2026, though, as he is set to earn a base salary of nearly $3.7 million through the NFL's proven performance escalator.
Beyond the tackle total, Winters added eight tackles for loss, three quarterback hits, an interception returned for a touchdown, and five passes defensed in 2025.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' Brock Purdy reveals impact of Dre Greenlaw's return
Linebacker Dre Greenlaw returned to the San Francisco 49ers this offseason after spending the 2025 season with the Denver Broncos. His reunion with All-Pro linebacker Fred Warner has many fans excited about the potential impact the duo can have on the defense in... -
49ers have learned to keep secrets, but is this a good thing?
For years, the San Francisco 49ers had a reputation for being one of the easiest NFL teams to get information from. Not because the team was particularly transparent, but because information seemed to find its way out of the building. That changed in 2017. Since Kyle Shanahan... -
49ers' Trent Williams embraces final NFL chapter, savoring every training camp moment
San Francisco 49ers left tackle Trent Williams made it clear that his current contract, which runs through the 2027 season, will likely be the final deal of his illustrious NFL career. Speaking to reporters after the 49ers' first training camp practice on Sunday, Williams was... -
Nick Bosa seriously doubts Joey Bosa will join the 49ers
The San Francisco 49ers expect the return of defensive end Nick Bosa to provide a significant boost to a pass rush that managed an NFL-low 20 sacks last season. However, if the unit continues to struggle in 2026, many believe the team could explore adding another proven...