McCaffrey also continued to climb the NFL record books. He surpassed LaDainian Tomlinson for the third-most receptions by a running back in league history. He became the first at the position to record at least 100 receptions in three separate seasons. His 102 catches were his most since 2019.
With 924 receiving yards, McCaffrey joined elite company as just one of three running backs in NFL history to log multiple seasons with at least 900 receiving yards (2019, 2025), alongside Marshall Faulk and Lenny Moore.
On the surface, it looked like another dominant year—one that mirrored (or at least approached) his 2023 NFL Offensive Player of the Year campaign. ESPN's Dan Graziano, however, isn't convinced the impact was quite as strong.
"McCaffrey averaged only 3.9 yards per carry this season," Graziano wrote. "That figure ranked 39th in the NFL, right behind Isiah Pacheco and ahead of Chuba Hubbard. And the 49ers' run game was very average, ranking 22nd in rush EPA. McCaffrey's contributions as a receiver are what made his season special and helped win fantasy leagues and drag the banged-up 49ers into the playoffs. But overall, his 2025 season doesn't hold a candle to 2023."
The efficiency dip is hard to ignore. McCaffrey's 3.9 yards per carry marked his lowest average since 2020 and the third-lowest of his career. He surpassed 1,000 rushing yards for the fifth time, but did so on a career-high 311 carries. His 413 total touches led the NFL, underscoring just how heavily the 49ers leaned on him throughout the season.
"The starkest difference is in early-down efficiency," Graziano continued. "On first and second down in 2023, McCaffrey averaged 5.4 yards per carry, had 1,337 rushing yards, and scored 14 rushing touchdowns. This season, those same numbers were 3.9 yards per carry, 1,064 rushing yards, and seven rushing touchdowns. Workmanlike, for sure, but not spectacular."
As the 49ers prepare for their Wild Card matchup against the Philadelphia Eagles, the question now is whether McCaffrey can elevate his play when it matters most and help push San Francisco deeper into the postseason.
"Again, McCaffrey was what the 49ers needed him to be this season -- a volume eater and target mismatch in the passing game," Graziano concluded. "But he's not the explosive early-down difference-maker that he was a couple of years ago when the 49ers made it all the way to overtime in the Super Bowl."
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers rank among NFL's best RB duos despite uncertainty behind Christian McCaffrey
When discussing the best running back situations in the NFL, it's difficult to overlook the San Francisco 49ers. The team has one of the league's most dynamic players in Christian McCaffrey, giving San Francisco one of the NFL's most dangerous backfields. CBS Sports' Jared... -
49ers' Brock Purdy reveals impact of Dre Greenlaw's return
Linebacker Dre Greenlaw returned to the San Francisco 49ers this offseason after spending the 2025 season with the Denver Broncos. His reunion with All-Pro linebacker Fred Warner has many fans excited about the potential impact the duo can have on the defense in... -
49ers rookie Romello Height avoids serious injury after being carted off the practice field
San Francisco 49ers rookie defensive end Romello Height suffered an injury during Monday's practice, the second session of training camp. The third-round pick was carted off the field following a concerning moment. Scary moment at practice and rookie 49ers DL Romello Height is... -
Only three 49ers would fetch a first-round pick in trade, says ESPN analyst
The San Francisco 49ers are widely regarded as one of the NFL's most talented teams. However, questions remain about the aging core of the roster and the team's recent injury history. Despite losing several key contributors to injuries last season, the 49ers still reached the...