Jeremiah's rankings were based on where each player appeared within his top-150 prospect rankings for the 2026 NFL Draft. For example, quarterback Fernando Mendoza was Jeremiah's top-ranked prospect, giving him a value of 150 points. The Las Vegas Raiders owned the No. 1 overall pick, which was worth 150 points, matching the expected value exactly.
From there, the No. 2 overall pick was worth 149 points, the No. 3 pick was worth 148 points, and so on throughout the draft.
Any player selected outside Jeremiah's top 150 was assigned zero points, as were draft slots outside the top 150.
The Indianapolis Colts finished atop the rankings, earning 392 total points from their draft selections despite having picks valued at 225 expected points. That gave Indianapolis a return of 174.2% above expected value.
Meanwhile, the 49ers totaled 172 points from their draft class, while their draft slots carried an expected value of 340 points. That significant gap left San Francisco with roughly half of the expected return, placing the team last in Jeremiah's rankings.
The 49ers have faced criticism from analysts for what many viewed as reaches throughout the draft, and Jeremiah's evaluation reflected that sentiment. However, projecting draft value remains highly subjective, especially before any of the prospects have played an NFL snap.
Last week, analytics site Pro Football Focus (PFF) released its own evaluation of the 2026 NFL Draft classes, focusing on each team's reach-to-steal ratio. PFF labeled seven of the 49ers' eight draft picks as reaches—several by substantial margins—resulting in a "D" grade for San Francisco.
When asked about the perception that the 49ers frequently reach on draft picks and deviate from outside consensus boards, general manager John Lynch offered a blunt response.
"Well, I appreciate that you think that," Lynch said. "It depends on whose consensus. We've got consensus in this building, and that's the consensus that I care about."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers rank among NFL's best RB duos despite uncertainty behind Christian McCaffrey
When discussing the best running back situations in the NFL, it's difficult to overlook the San Francisco 49ers. The team has one of the league's most dynamic players in Christian McCaffrey, giving San Francisco one of the NFL's most dangerous backfields. CBS Sports' Jared... -
49ers' Deommodore Lenoir among PFF's make-or-break players for 2026
Pro Football Focus (PFF) wasn't particularly impressed with San Francisco 49ers cornerback Deommodore Lenoir's 2025 season. The veteran earned a 60.3 overall defensive grade from the analytics site—his lowest since his rookie campaign. His 65.7 coverage grade marked his... -
49ers' Brock Purdy: Where does he actually rank among fantasy QBs?
CBS Sports' Heath Cummings recently unveiled his fantasy football quarterback tiers, and San Francisco 49ers fans may be interested to see where Brock Purdy landed heading into the 2026 fantasy football season. Cummings divided his quarterback rankings into seven tiers, with... -
49ers executive Paraag Marathe reportedly among finalists for MLS Commissioner
Major League Soccer is searching for a successor to Commissioner Don Garber, and one of the reported finalists could be a familiar—and potentially concerning—name for San Francisco 49ers fans. According to John Ourand of Puck, the search has been narrowed to three...