While still early in the NFL offseason, many are wondering if the reigning NFL Defensive Player of the Year could be on the move.
Several reporters have explored which teams might pursue Garrett if the Browns decide to trade him. Naturally, the San Francisco 49ers are frequently mentioned whenever a top-tier pass rusher is available.
49ers eye pass-rush help
San Francisco's defense struggled last season, recording just 20 total sacks, the fewest in the NFL. With Nick Bosa and Mykel Williams recovering from ACL injuries—and Bryce Huff's sudden retirement—edge rusher has become a clear positional need for the team.
CBS Sports analyst John Breech weighed in on a potential Garrett-to-49ers trade:
"Garrett had more sacks last season (23) than the 49ers did as a team (20). San Francisco finished with the fewest sacks in the NFL and needs any help it can get in the pass-rushing department. The team has already signed 33-year-old Mike Evans and appears all-in for 2026, making a Garrett trade the ultimate aggressive move."
Meanwhile, Sports Illustrated's Conor Orr also sees a Garrett trade as plausible. He wrote:
"This would be an interesting long-term gamble on behalf of the Browns. While the 49ers are an excellent, top-10 team right now, their aging roster presents the possibility of a few injuries derailing a season and making future 49ers draft capital look immensely valuable. In the Kyle Shanahan era, San Francisco has picked third, ninth, second and 11th (though some of those higher picks were the result of a trade up). The 49ers are moving like a team that acknowledges upgrades are necessary to compete in an increasingly competitive NFC West, and Garrett would dramatically raise the efficacy of star pass rusher Nick Bosa in the interim. This would be a salvo fired directly toward the less-mobile Stafford and bootleg-dependent Sam Darnold within the division."
What's next for Garrett?
It's unclear what will happen with Garrett this offseason. He could just continue playing on the four-year, $160 million deal signed last year, which kept him in Cleveland.
With 125.5 career sacks—including 23 in 2025—the potential of Garrett joining another team is enough to excite any fanbase dreaming of adding a top-tier pass rush.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers floated as 'team to watch' for blockbuster QB trade—but the logic has one major flaw
A feature from longtime sports journalist Vincent Bonsignore of the California Post generated plenty of buzz on Friday—not because of his evaluation of Brock Purdy, but because of one intriguing claim involving the San Francisco 49ers and Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe... -
Only three 49ers would fetch a first-round pick in trade, says ESPN analyst
The San Francisco 49ers are widely regarded as one of the NFL's most talented teams. However, questions remain about the aging core of the roster and the team's recent injury history. Despite losing several key contributors to injuries last season, the 49ers still reached the... -
Is 49ers QB Mac Jones too valuable to trade?
The San Francisco 49ers arguably have one of the NFL's strongest quarterback rooms, with Brock Purdy entrenched as the starter and Mac Jones serving as one of the league's most proven backups. In fact, without Jones, the 49ers might not have reached the playoffs last... -
Christian Kirk injury gives 49ers' young wide receivers greater opportunity to make their mark in training camp
The San Francisco 49ers entered the 2026 offseason with a very different look at wide receiver. The additions of veteran players Mike Evans and Christian Kirk gave the team two experienced weapons to pair with Ricky Pearsall, while also creating a much more crowded competition...