If the 49ers spend a first-round pick on a future replacement, the benefit is clear. A rookie would have the rare opportunity to sit and develop behind one of the greatest offensive linemen in NFL history. That kind of experience is invaluable, especially at a premium position like left tackle.
The downside? San Francisco would be investing its top selection in a player unlikely to make an immediate impact. The 49ers must carefully weigh short-term roster needs against long-term roster needs.
With the NFL Scouting Combine underway, ESPN draft analyst Mel Kiper Jr. released his latest mock draft, projecting the 49ers to select former Alabama offensive lineman Kadyn Proctor at No. 27 overall.
The selection of Proctor might be a bit of a gamble on the 49ers' part. Kiper characterizes him as a true developmental prospect. The offensive lineman has high upside, but the analyst remains concerned with his floor.
"Proctor's tape is all over the place," Kiper wrote. "The highs are really, really good. The lows raise a lot of questions. But in the right situation, he could become a standout tackle in the NFL. And there might not be a better situation than learning behind one of the best to ever do it in San Francisco. Trent Williams will be 38 by Week 1, and he's entering the final year of his contract."
From an analytics standpoint, Proctor closed his collegiate career on a strong note. According to Pro Football Focus, he posted career-best marks in 2025 with an 86.1 overall offensive grade, an 81.1 run-blocking grade, and an 84.2 pass-blocking grade. He surrendered 21 pressures and two sacks across 611 pass-blocking snaps.
At 6-foot-7 and 366 pounds, Proctor possesses rare size, so the upside is apparent.
"So, Proctor could develop in Year 1 while kicking inside to guard and/or playing a swing tackle role before perhaps taking over for Williams in 2027," Kiper added. "He has 40 career starts -- all at left tackle -- and is reliable in pass protection. This would be an upside pick for GM John Lynch."
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers have reason to believe Brock Purdy will prove latest ranking wrong
There is disrespect, and then there is whatever this is. Recently, San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy found himself on the wrong side of the latest quarterback ranking. Matt Verderame of Sports Illustrated released his preseason quarterback rankings and placed Purdy... -
Deebo Samuel's Latest Comments Are a Powerful Reminder of His 49ers Legacy
Deebo Samuel remains unsigned, but he's confident that his best football is still ahead of him. As training camps begin across the league, Samuel is still one of the top free agents available. In a video on his YouTube channel, he dismissed the idea that his career is... -
Ranking the 49ers rookies primed for an immediate 2026 impact
The San Francisco 49ers don't need every rookie to become an instant starter. They just need a handful to fill meaningful roles on a roster that is once again hopeful of a Super Bowl run. And with rookies reporting to training camp today, we'll begin to get a good look at what... -
Can the 49ers' aging core hold on? Insider reveals top concern for 2026
The San Francisco 49ers enter the 2026 season with legitimate Super Bowl aspirations, as they have for several years. The roster is talented enough to make another deep playoff run, but can the team keep pace in what could be the NFL's toughest division? The NFC West features...