In a recent ranking by NFL analyst Aaron Schatz, the 2025 Seahawks ranked No. 3 among the 60 Super Bowl champions. It's a stunning placement—and notably higher than any Super Bowl-winning San Francisco 49ers team.
The 1991 Washington Redskins and 1985 Chicago Bears claimed the top two spots, respectively. The highest-ranked 49ers team was the dominant 1989 squad, which landed at No. 4.
It's worth noting that Schatz's rankings rely heavily on his proprietary DVOA (defense-adjusted value over average) metric, which evaluates teams based on play-by-play efficiency while adjusting for situation and opponent quality.
Here's where the 49ers' five Super Bowl championship teams ranked:
- 1989 49ers: No. 4
- 1984 49ers: No. 12
- 1994 49ers: No. 18
- 1988 49ers: No. 28
- 1981 49ers: No. 55
According to Schatz, both the 2025 Seahawks and the Los Angeles Rams have graded out as top-10 teams since 1978, measured by DVOA. He also cited Seattle's strength of schedule and the fact that its three losses came by a combined nine points.
"Seattle's 41-6 victory over the No. 6-seed 49ers in the divisional round was the strongest single game of the season played by any team," Schatz wrote. "Then came a 31-27 NFC championship win over the No. 5-seed Rams. Finally, the Seahawks dispatched the Patriots 29-13 to win Super Bowl LX and claim their second title.
"There's a big DVOA gap between the 2025 Seahawks and our top two teams. Only one non-Super Bowl champion would fall into this space, the 2007 Patriots at 50.8%. The last two teams are clearly the top teams of the Super Bowl era, and each has its own good arguments for why it should be No. 1."
While the 2025 Seahawks were undeniably talented and fielded an impressive and punishing defense, ranking them above every 49ers Super Bowl champion is certain to spark debate. Metrics like DVOA offer valuable context, but relying heavily on a single analytical model can yield surprising—and controversial—results, as seen in Schatz's ranking.
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers urged to sign two-time Super Bowl champion to bolster defense
Veteran NFL edge rusher Kyle Van Noy has made it clear he would welcome the opportunity to play for the San Francisco 49ers. Bleacher Report's Kristopher Knox believes the fit makes sense for coordinator Raheem Morris' defense. Knox recently identified the top NFL free agents... -
49ers preseason: NFL Network and ESPN to air all three games
The NFL Network and ESPN have announced their preseason broadcast schedules, and all three San Francisco 49ers preseason games will be available to a national audience. Fans in the Bay Area can watch the games locally on KPIX. Those outside the 49ers' home television market... -
ESPN's ranking of 49ers' under-25 talent raises red flags
Much has been made of the San Francisco 49ers' aging roster as the team prepares for the 2026 NFL season. While the core remains loaded with proven veterans, questions continue to grow about how long that group can keep the team's Super Bowl window open. Sustained success in... -
Only three 49ers would fetch a first-round pick in trade, says ESPN analyst
The San Francisco 49ers are widely regarded as one of the NFL's most talented teams. However, questions remain about the aging core of the roster and the team's recent injury history. Despite losing several key contributors to injuries last season, the 49ers still reached the...