Which San Francisco 49ers team from the past 25 years was the best?
ESPN's Bill Barnwell released his rankings of the 25 best NFL teams over the last quarter-century, and one San Francisco 49ers squad made the cut.
The Niners' franchise has fielded several notable teams over the past 25 seasons, including Kyle Shanahan's recent Super Bowl squads and Jim Harbaugh's early 2010s contenders. However, Barnwell's actual selection, which he admits "seems like a curious choice," is likely to come as a surprise—and perhaps warrants further exploration.
Do you want a clue? How about a name?
"Kyle Williams"
20. 2011 San Francisco 49ers (14-4)
Fate: Lost NFC Championship Game to Giants 20-17
Offense: 65th percentile
Defense: 98th percentile
Barnwell didn't pick the 2011 49ers team out of a hat; clearly, a lot of thought and analysis went into his selection, regardless of whether you agree.
He immediately addressed the most obvious question: "I wouldn't fault you for picking the 2012 team, but the 2011 49ers were more imposing on defense, allowing just over 14 points per game." Barnwell pointed out that "the 2012 49ers didn't have as impressive a regular season record," but also recognized that the 2012 team faced a tougher regular season schedule, along with a Super Bowl run that fell "just short."
Notably, there was no mention of the 49ers' recent "Dynasty of Almost."
In the end, Barnwell's decision was based in part on San Francisco's wild playoff run. "They won my pick for the best NFL game I've ever covered, a brutal, dramatic and eventually cathartic 36-32 victory over the Saints in the divisional round," Barnwell explained.
"One win away from the Super Bowl, they were engaged in a defensive struggle against the Giants in the NFC Championship Game, only for it to be decided when returner Kyle Williams muffed two punts to set up the tying touchdown in the fourth quarter and the winning field goal in overtime."
"The Niners deserved better," Barnwell concluded.
Well, that's something we can all agree on.
Written By:
You may have seen Chris Wilson's work on NFL game theory, statistical analysis, and film breakdowns at On SI, FanSided, Niner Noise, LockedonSports, Insidethe49, ClutchPoints, and others. Follow Chris on Twitter @cgawilson.
All articles by Chris Wilson
Chris Wilson
You may have seen Chris Wilson's work on NFL game theory, statistical analysis, and film breakdowns at On SI, FanSided, Niner Noise, LockedonSports, Insidethe49, ClutchPoints, and others. Follow Chris on Twitter @cgawilson.
All articles by Chris Wilson
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Writer urges 49ers to consider trading one player—at the right price
There was plenty of speculation surrounding San Francisco 49ers quarterback Mac Jones this offseason. Many believed the team could trade Brock Purdy's backup before or during the 2026 NFL Draft. That never materialized, and Jones appears poised to remain Purdy's primary backup... -
49ers' Mike Evans left off ESPN's top-10 wide receiver rankings
The San Francisco 49ers signed veteran wide receiver Mike Evans this offseason as part of a major overhaul of their receiving corps. The hope is that the six-time Pro Bowler and Super Bowl champion can elevate the offense while giving quarterback Brock Purdy a dependable... -
49ers' Brock Purdy left out of ESPN's top-10 quarterback rankings
The debate over where San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy ranks among the NFL's elite continues. ESPN's Jeremy Fowler continued his annual NFL position rankings this week, unveiling his list of the league's top quarterbacks. The rankings are based on feedback from NFL... -
Where 49ers' Fred Warner landed in ESPN's off-ball linebacker rankings after injury
San Francisco 49ers linebacker Fred Warner remains one of the NFL's most respected defensive players. Although he missed 11 games last season after suffering a dislocated and fractured right ankle, the All-Pro linebacker still earned the top spot in a prominent offseason...