Depending on what the 49ers receive in return—there is word that the team seeks a veteran wideout in addition to draft compensation—the loss of Aiyuk could impact the team's Super Bowl odds. ESPN's Joe Fortenbaugh expressed his belief that the 49ers' Super Bowl window isn't just closing but has already closed.
Fortenbaugh believes Aiyuk has some leverage in this process. While the 49ers could control the player's rights for the next three years through a combination of the fifth-year option and franchise tag, the team is desperate to win a Super Bowl, and Aiyuk's presence increases their chances.
"They know that the window's closing," Fortenbaugh said on ESPN's First Take. "I think the window is actually closed, and I think this trade would end up putting the stake in the coffin."
Fortenbaugh acknowledges that even without Aiyuk, the 49ers' roster is still talented. However, the team couldn't overcome the Kansas City Chiefs in the Super Bowl during a relatively healthy 2023 campaign with Aiyuk. Would they be able to beat the odds and return?
"Curse of the Super Bowl loser. What is that?" Fortenbaugh continued. "There's a pretty good explanation, several. One of which is to get to the Super Bowl, you have to be one of the healthiest teams in the NFL. Health is something that's very difficult to replicate year after year. ... If you're a very healthy team like San Francisco was last year, like Philadelphia was two years ago, you're going to experience more injuries next year. It's just the law of averages.
"As those injuries kick in for the Niners this year, the production's going to fall off. They face eight teams this year that are going to have a scheduling advantage against them, and if you take Brandon Aiyuk off the table, Deebo Samuel, who's battled injuries in the past. George Kittle, who's battled injuries in the past. Christian McCaffrey, who's battled injuries in the past. That offense is coming back down. That Super Bowl window is closed."
Courtney Cronin added that if Aiyuk is not on the 49ers' roster in 2024, the Los Angeles Rams should be considered the better team in the NFC.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Steve Mariucci: 49ers' Brock Purdy has already proven he's good enough to win a Super Bowl
There has been no shortage of pressure placed on Brock Purdy heading into the 2026 season. After signing a massive long-term contract last year, Purdy is no longer the surprise seventh-round quarterback trying to prove he belongs. He is now firmly established as the San... -
49ers Rookie Kaelon Black Has Chance to Seize RB2 Role Against Chargers
Many starters are in line to play tonight for the San Francisco 49ers as they take the field for their second preseason game, this time against the Los Angeles Chargers. Running back Christian McCaffrey and wide receiver Mike Evans are both dealing with tightness, while tight... -
49ers record prediction has team missing playoffs during 2026 season
The battle for the NFC West crown in 2026 should be a competitive one, but some believe that competition could ultimately lead to trouble for the San Francisco 49ers. Bleacher Report's Moe Moton recently released his record predictions for the 2026 NFL season, and he has the... -
49ers TE George Kittle's 'eye-popping' recovery progress has Rapoport impressed
There may be some who doubt that San Francisco 49ers tight end George Kittle will be ready to suit up for Week 1 after suffering a torn Achilles in last season's playoffs. NFL Network insider Ian Rapoport is not among the doubters. Rapoport had an opportunity to observe Kittle...