49ers overreactions: Is Brandon Aiyuk's return even needed for team to win?

The 49ers scored 41 points against the Arizona Cardinals on Sunday, as their offense was as close to full strength as it has been all 2025 NFL season.Tight end George Kittle exited in the first half of Week 1 with a hamstring injury that kept him out for five games. Quarterback Brock Purdy and wide receiver Ricky Pearsall were back Sunday after missing the past six games.In addition, receiver Jauan Jennings is getting healthier, and the offensive line is at full strength.The only player missing from the ideal 49ers offense is wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk, who has not practiced since sustaining a severe knee injury in Week 7 of last year.There is no indication when (or if) Aiyuk will play this season.Yes, a fully healthy and well-polished Aiyuk would help the 49ers. But is it asking too much to expect him to provide any kind of boost this season?It’s time to weigh in for another edition of 49ers Overreactions.With how the offense looked, there is no need for Aiyuk. He will never be seen in a 49er uniform again. (&commat;Canadian&lowbar;49er)Overreaction? No.Coach Kyle Shanahan and general manager John Lynch have not closed the door on Brandon Aiyuk’s return this season.Their comments always seem to lean a little more on the positive side. But it appears as if they also realize Aiyuk might not step on the field this season.“No absolutes there,” Lynch said last week on his weekly KNBR appearance, “and you just take it as it comes there.”If Aiyuk returns off the physically-unable-to-perform list and is able to play at a high level, that’s found money. Whether they need him or not is a good discussion point.“When you have such a big injury like that, you wait until he’s fully comfortable to come up and start practicing,” Shanahan said Monday.Right now, the 49ers have Jennings, Pearsall, Kendrick Bourne and Demarcus Robinson as their top four wide receivers.As for the future, Aiyuk is under contract through the 2028 season after signing a four-year, &dollar;120 million extension before the 2024 campaign. But, as we’ve learned with lucrative, long-term contracts in the NFL, there are no absolutes there, either.That is why just about anything seems possible at this point.Our secondary issues will continue as long as we insist on playing Upton Stout, a liability (&commat;SandHillRude)Overreaction? Yes.Hmmm. I don’t see this one.Has it been perfect? Of course not. But Stout made a couple of really nice plays on Sunday that contributed to takeaways in the 49ers’ 41-22 victory over the Cardinals.Stout had phenomenal coverage at the end of the first half against Arizona slot receiver Greg Dortch that might have forced a bad throw from quarterback Jacoby Brissett. That pass ended up being intercepted by Malik Mustapha.Then, Stout stripped Cardinals tight end Elijah Higgins at the goal line to prevent a touchdown and force a takeaway.“He competes in the run game as much as anyone on our team,” Shanahan said Monday. “And I love how he runs and hits out there. He’s been beat a few times, and that’s stuff I know he’ll continue to get better at because he’s got the skillset to do it and he’s got the work ethic and the character to do it, too.”Nickel back is the most difficult defensive position to play. Stout gave up a 34-yard pass to Michael Wilson in the first quarter. He was called for pass interference on the play, though that was debatable. His coverage was good. It just wasn’t good enough. He will get better at finishing those plays with experience.And let’s remember, Stout is a rookie. He should continue to learn and improve. He finally has given the 49ers a player in that all-important spot who should be around for a long time.We needed Jaelan Phillips wayyy more then the Eagles and should’ve made it happen (&commat;IgamblesoGFY)Overreaction? Yes.The first part is true. The 49ers could have used Jaelan Phillips as part of their D-line rotation. There’s no question about it.But the Philadelphia Eagles sent a third-round pick in the 2026 NFL Draft to the Miami Dolphins to make that trade happen. The 49ers were wise to hold onto their draft selections in each of the first three rounds.Phillips is signed only through the remainder of this season. That’s a stiff price to pay for a player who will be with the team for half the season.Also, Phillips is an injury risk the 49ers should have been reluctant to take on — especially at such a high price. He sustained a torn Achilles in 2023 and a torn ACL last season.How can the Niners win a playoff game with no pass rush and DBs who miss tackles and allow a backup QB to have 450 yards passing? (&commat;Truckeelocal)Overreaction? No.Unlike the TV game show “Jeopardy&excl;” we ask that you refrain from submitting your overreaction in the form of a question. But we’ll make an exception this one time.If the 49ers advance to the postseason, it will be difficult for them to go on the road and slow down any playoff-caliber offense with a pass rush that does not have a whole lot to offer.The 49ers have a league-worst 12 quarterback sacks in 11 games. Cardinals quarterback Jacoby Brissett dropped back 57 times on Sunday. He was not sacked, and he was hit only four times.That is not good enough, and it seems unlikely to be a winning formula in the postseason.The 49ers can beat any team in the NFL if they play mistake free football (&commat;MichaelGeo2213)Overreaction? No.The Los Angeles Rams might be the best team in the NFL. The 49ers defeated them in Week 5. The 49ers are now a different team, though. All-Pro linebacker Fred Warner sustained a season-ending injury the following week, but they also now have Purdy, Kittle and Pearsall back.The 49ers are nowhere close to being the top team in the NFL. But — as the saying goes — on any given Sunday if they play a clean game and have a plus-turnover margin, yes, they can spring an upset against anyone.Download and follow the 49ers Talk Podcast

49ers overreactions: Is Brandon Aiyuk’s return even needed for team to win?

Similar Article Found

49ers void Brandon Aiyuk's guarantees, appear headed for split

Read Next

Latest

Trending News