However, Ralph Vacchiano of FOX Sports suggests an alternative path—one that involves a trade. Vacchiano identified Nick Herbig of the Pittsburgh Steelers as the ideal target for San Francisco during the draft.
The proposed cost: a 2026 second-round pick (No. 58 overall) and a 2027 conditional fifth-round selection.
"Their pass rush was completely punchless last season, with Bryce Huff leading the team with just four sacks," Vacchiano wrote.
Huff, by the way, has since retired, leaving the 49ers in even greater need of reinforcements. Additionally, Nick Bosa and Mykel Williams are coming off ACL injuries that shortened their 2025 campaigns.
"They are hopeful that both Nick Bosa and Mykel Williams will be healthy and back in their old form next season, but they could use another body in the rotation," Vacchiano added. "Herbig, 24, is stuck in a rotation behind T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith in Pittsburgh and in the final year of his contract. He had 13 sacks in a limited role over the past two seasons and would be well worth the high pick it would probably cost for the Steelers to swap him."
Herbig recorded a career-high 7.5 sacks in 2025 and has totaled 16 sacks over his three-year NFL career, according to Pro Football Reference. He has also compiled 79 tackles (23 for loss), 32 quarterback hits, one interception, three passes defensed, and nine forced fumbles—impressive production for a player with just 11 starts across 45 games.
Advanced metrics further highlight his potential. Herbig earned an 87.3 pass-rush grade in 2025 and a 91.5 grade in 2024 from Pro Football Focus, while generating 48 total pressures last season. His 72.7 run-defense grade in 2025 also underscores his potential appeal to the 49ers.
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers urged to sign two-time Super Bowl champion to bolster defense
Veteran NFL edge rusher Kyle Van Noy has made it clear he would welcome the opportunity to play for the San Francisco 49ers. Bleacher Report's Kristopher Knox believes the fit makes sense for coordinator Raheem Morris' defense. Knox recently identified the top NFL free agents... -
49ers floated as 'team to watch' for blockbuster QB trade—but the logic has one major flaw
A feature from longtime sports journalist Vincent Bonsignore of the California Post generated plenty of buzz on Friday—not because of his evaluation of Brock Purdy, but because of one intriguing claim involving the San Francisco 49ers and Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe... -
Is 49ers QB Mac Jones too valuable to trade?
The San Francisco 49ers arguably have one of the NFL's strongest quarterback rooms, with Brock Purdy entrenched as the starter and Mac Jones serving as one of the league's most proven backups. In fact, without Jones, the 49ers might not have reached the playoffs last... -
Only three 49ers would fetch a first-round pick in trade, says ESPN analyst
The San Francisco 49ers are widely regarded as one of the NFL's most talented teams. However, questions remain about the aging core of the roster and the team's recent injury history. Despite losing several key contributors to injuries last season, the 49ers still reached the...